James A. MARCUM
The Metaphysical Foundations of Human Cloning
Os Fundamentos Metafísicos da Clonagem Humana
Published in The Foundations of Bioethics
Keywords: Holism – Human cloning – Methodological reductionism – Ontological reductionism – Reproductive technology.
PDF download:
![application/pdf PDF icon](/modules/file/icons/application-pdf.png)
The presuppositions upon which human reproductive cloning technology relies are examined, in order to address the debate over human uniqueness and identity, as well as dignity and flourishing. To that end, the presupposition of reductionism that animates the modern biomedical sciences is initially explored. As methodological reductionism, reductionism is important for conducting scientific research; but as ontological reductionism, it is often insufficient for interpreting the cultural or social meaning of scientific data. The distinction between methodological and ontological reductionism is necessary to address the debate surrounding reproductive cloning technology and human nature and flourishing. Scientists and others who depend upon empirical research would be better served by shifting from ontological reductionism to holism, when interpreting scientific data on human cloning in terms of their social meaning and impact on public policy.